Britain | Bagehot

Rishi Sunak and Sir Keir Starmer fight for a poundshop presidency 

The general election reveals the absurdities of Britain’s presidential turn

Illustration of Keir Starmer and Rishi Sunak wrapped in cheap toy packaging.
Photograph: Nate Kitch

Neither Rishi Sunak nor Sir Keir Starmer is a natural politician. That may be a strange thing to say about a man who was the youngest prime minister since 1812 and an opponent who is on track for a historically large majority. But in a less feral era of British politics, Sir Keir would have capped off a successful legal career with a few years as attorney-general and Mr Sunak would still be a mid-ranking cabinet minister rather than the boss. Extreme events put both in a high place, like a fishing boat marooned halfway up a hill after a tsunami.

All their flaws and frailties were on display during their first televised head-to-head debate on June 4th. Neither shone. Mr Sunak has two registers: simpering and hectoring. When members of the public laid out their hardship stories, Mr Sunak responded with the learned empathy of a man worth £651m ($830m). When the debate moved to technical matters, he responded with the pernickety fluency of an over-promoted junior minister. Sir Keir, meanwhile, is remarkably wooden for a former barrister, clumsily dragging every other question back to his tenure running the Crown Prosecution Service. The viewer was left pleasantly surprised that anyone was jailed during his stint there.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Britain section of the print edition under the headline “A poundshop presidency”

A triumph for Indian democracy

From the June 8th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Britain

Labour sweet-talks the public sector

The race to become leader of Britain’s Conservatives

An exhausted party seems to think that it doesn’t have to change


How deep is Britain’s fiscal “black hole”?

Rachel Reeves sets out her first big decisions as chancellor


Shabana Mahmood, Britain’s new Lord Chancellor

The new justice secretary is both progressive and religious

How King Charles III counts his swans

A ritual that pleases conservationists and annoys the birds

Britain’s army chief fears war may come sooner than anyone thinks

Could the army cope without more money and troops?