Britain | Bagehot

The secret to good government? Actually trying 

Effort always beats ideas in British politics

illustration of Keir Starmer being admonished by Beckett, depicted in headmaster attire. Beckett is pointing his finger at Starmer in a stern manner, emphasizing the need for Starmer to try harder. The background is red
Illustration: Nate Kitch

The power of a new government stems not from its ideas but its enthusiasm. Labour, which took power on July 5th, kicked off with a flurry of green measures approved with the simple squiggle of a minister’s pen. Three giant solar farms were nodded through. A ban on onshore wind farms was removed by ministerial diktat. Or as Sir Keir Starmer, the prime minister, put it in peculiarly teenage syntax: “It was just, like, ‘delete’.”

A new government is a reminder of an old lesson: effort is the most underrated force in British politics. What governments should do is endlessly debated; how they should do it is almost completely ignored. In his book “How To Run A Government”, Sir Michael Barber, a former New Labour adviser and perhaps the most effective aide of the past half-century, sets out a rule of thumb: “Policy is 10% and implementation 90%.” In politics, in other words, trying is nearly everything.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Britain section of the print edition under the headline “The secret of good government? Trying”

When markets ignore politics

From the July 20th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Britain

Labour sweet-talks the public sector

The race to become leader of Britain’s Conservatives

An exhausted party seems to think that it doesn’t have to change


How deep is Britain’s fiscal “black hole”?

Rachel Reeves sets out her first big decisions as chancellor


Shabana Mahmood, Britain’s new Lord Chancellor

The new justice secretary is both progressive and religious

How King Charles III counts his swans

A ritual that pleases conservationists and annoys the birds

Britain’s army chief fears war may come sooner than anyone thinks

Could the army cope without more money and troops?