Graphic detail | Bad vibrations

The pandemic has broken a closely followed survey of sentiment

Americans’ opinions about the state of the economy have diverged from reality

Americans are gloomy about the state of the economy. Since the covid-19 pandemic began, consumer sentiment has been in the doldrums, hitting its lowest level ever in June 2022. Such negativity has prompted claims that the country is suffering a “vibecession”—although the market appears healthy, good vibes are lacking.

Changes in consumer sentiment are normally a useful economic benchmark. The longest-running measure comes from a survey by the University of Michigan, which began in 1946. Each month it asks a representative sample of 600 Americans a set of five questions probing their opinions on their own finances and spending, the state of the wider economy, and the outlook for both. For most of the past four decades the index has moved in lock-step with changes in current consumer spending, and also loosely predicted spending a year ahead.

This article appeared in the Graphic detail section of the print edition under the headline “Bad vibrations”

Chart sources: University of Michigan; FRED; The Economist

Growth industry: Wealth management for the many

From the September 9th 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Graphic detail

Which countries would be most affected by a second Trump term?

A ranking of America’s 70 largest trading partners

How long would it take to read the greatest books of all time?

The Economist consulted bibliophile data scientists to bring you the answer


Why 2024 could become the hottest year on record

Global temperatures reach record highs twice in less than a week


Donald Trump is now the oldest candidate to run for president

But America’s issue with ageing politicians goes beyond the White House

Which country has the most Olympic medals?

One dominates. But a tiny island shows there are numerous ways to measure sporting prowess

Can America afford its debts?

Public debt stands at 98% of GDP. Neither Democrats nor Republicans are helping